Synthetic vs. Natural Fragrance: What’s the Difference?
Natural isn’t always safer, and synthetic isn’t always worse. A plain-language guide to how fine fragrance is made.
By Margaret · · 4 min read
Synthetic fragrance gets a bad rap, and I don’t think that reputation is entirely deserved. I get why a candle scented with real roses sounds more appealing than one made with a fragrance from a lab. But how many roses did it take to make the oil? And if what you love is the smell of a fresh rose petal, could a perfumer give you that same note using fewer resources? I think it’s worth understanding how both fragrances are made before deciding which one you’d rather bring into your home.
How natural fragrance is made
A natural fragrance ingredient starts with aromatic material that’s already there in a flower, a fruit peel, a seed, or a piece of wood. How you get it out depends on where it is. You can press the peel of a citrus fruit to release its oil. With Damask roses, one traditional way to capture their scent is to pick the flowers early in the morning and distill them while they’re fresh.
This is the part that’s hard to picture. Fragrance house Firmenrich says it takes about 3,500 kilograms of fresh Damask roses to produce one kilogram of essential oil. By its figures, that works out to roughly 1,150 flowers for a single gram. Imagine about a hundred bouquets of a dozen roses each.
To make the oil, a distiller heats the flowers with water or steam. The steam carries fragrant compounds out of the petals, then passes through a condenser, where it cools back into liquid. The distiller separates the small layer of rose oil from the fragrant water underneath. Both have a scent, and they smell different because some of the molecules in the petals dissolve more readily in water.
How rose oil becomes a fragrance
So now you have rose oil. What do you actually mix it with? That depends on the rose you want someone to smell. If I wanted a bright, fresh rose, a perfumer might blend the oil with bergamot peel oil. For something warmer and woodier, they might reach for cedarwood. A formula can use all botanical ingredients, or the perfumer can add individual scent molecules to emphasize a particular part of the rose.
That blend is the fragrance concentrate. To turn it into a spray perfume, it’s usually diluted in alcohol. To scent a candle, the concentrate is mixed into melted wax. So even a candle that smells unmistakably of one flower can have quite a few ingredients behind it.
How synthetic fragrance is made
With a synthetic ingredient, chemists start with other raw materials and use chemical reactions to build the scent molecule they want. Those starting materials can come from plants or from petrochemicals. Perfumers use synthetics to create new scents, and they also use them to recreate molecules that exist in nature. Phenethyl alcohol is a good example. It’s one of the molecules responsible for the soft, rosy smell you get when you put your nose up to a fresh rose.
Remember the rosewater from distillation? A lot of the flower’s phenethyl alcohol ends up there, which is one reason the oil smells different from the bloom. A perfumer can take that rose oil and blend in synthetic phenethyl alcohol to bring back some of the fresh-petal character. That’s what “nature-identical” means. The synthetic molecule has the same chemical structure as the one the rose made. It takes a whole blend to recreate the flower, but for that one note, you can get there either way.
When the synthetic process can be cleaner
Think about what went into that gram of rose oil. Someone grew and picked all those flowers, and the distillery needed water and heat to extract the oil. If a perfumer wants just one molecule that occurs in tiny amounts in a plant, making it directly can save a lot of raw material. How much it saves depends on how the synthetic version is made, too.
There’s a good example in a study published in Green Chemistry. Researchers compared two ways of making a fragrance ingredient called leaf alcohol, which smells like freshly cut grass. One route involved growing mint, distilling the leaves, and isolating the tiny amount of that molecule in the oil. The other made the same molecule synthetically. Even though the synthetic route used fossil-derived starting materials, it had a much lower overall environmental impact in that study. The sheer quantity of mint and the energy needed to distill it made the difference.
At the end of the day, I don’t think there’s one perfect answer. A flower grows above ground and fossil fuels from below it. Both come from nature, and the environmental cost of extracting and using fossil fuels is real. At Atmo, we care about where each ingredient comes from and what it takes to turn it into the scent you experience at home. For us, finding a better balance means looking at each step of that process and making small, consistent improvements wherever we can.