Holiday shipping: order by Nov 25 for the first night of Hanukkah · by Dec 16 for delivery by Dec 24
Clean living

How to Tell If a Candle Is Clean

What to look for in choosing a candle and how to burn it safely at home. 

By Margaret · · 4 min read
How to Tell If a Candle Is Clean

There’s a lot of misinformation out there about how to tell if a candle is clean. People will tell you that beeswax candles burn cleaner, that you should only buy soy, or that the whole problem is the fragrance. But there’s so much more to a clean burn than what’s in the wax. Here’s everything I’ve learned about choosing a cleaner candle, and it starts with understanding how a candle actually works.

How a candle works

A candle is chemistry in action. When you light the wick, the heat melts the wax around it. The wick draws that liquid wax up through its fibers, where the heat turns it into vapor. The wax vapor reacts with oxygen and keeps the flame burning. That’s combustion. When the wick delivers fuel at a rate the flame can burn efficiently, you get a steady flame with very little visible smoke or soot. 

How to tell if your candle is burning poorly

If your candle is just sitting there smoking while it burns, pay attention. You might see a black ring of soot around the rim, a flame that won’t stop trembling, or little black balls floating in the wax. Those bits can form when carbon builds up on the wick and falls into the melt pool. If the candle keeps smoking even with a trimmed wick and no draft, it may be poorly wicked. 

Tunneling is when a candle burns straight down the center and leaves a thick wall of wax around the sides. Short burns can cause it. If it keeps happening even when you follow the burn instructions, the wick may be too small for the vessel. 

What to look for when choosing a better candle

I always compare a McDonald’s cheeseburger with the cheeseburger you’d order at a nice restaurant. Both have beef, cheese, and a bun. The difference comes down to the quality of the ingredients and what the cook does with them. Cheap candles are cheap for a reason, too. Good wax and fragrance cost money, and so does the time it takes to test how they burn together.

The wax blend

I like a soy wax blend. A well-formulated one can burn beautifully, though a label that just says “soy blend” leaves out what the soy is blended with. I appreciate a brand that tells you which waxes it uses, even if it keeps the proportions to itself. As for the claim that burning beeswax purifies the air, there’s no good evidence for it. 

In a study co-funded by the National Candle Association, researchers tested unscented candles made from five waxes, including soy, paraffin, and beeswax. All five burned similarly under the test conditions. One detail worth knowing is that each wax had a wick chosen to suit it. 

The wick

Say you keep the wax and the jar exactly the same but change the fragrance. You may need a different wick. Someone has to burn that candle over and over, watch how it behaves as the flame gets lower in the jar, and try another wick if it smokes or tunnels. That takes time. If I’m paying more for a candle, I want to hear how the company did that work. 

The fragrance

Fragrance is the tricky one. There’s no single standard for what makes a candle fragrance “clean,” and fragrance houses often protect their formulas as trade secrets. Even if a brand can’t share the exact recipe, it can tell you which ingredients it leaves out and why. 

In candle fragrance, I look to avoid phthalates, nitromusks, and polycyclic musks. Certain phthalates have been linked to hormone disruption and effects on reproductive development. Nitromusks and polycyclic musks are two families of synthetic fragrance ingredients. Some break down so slowly that they linger in the environment. 

I also want a fragrance screened for known carcinogens and evaluated for use in a candle, because what matters here is what you breathe in as it burns. At Atmo, we formulate our candle fragrances to the Credo Clean Standard. Credo prohibits over 3,000 ingredients across the products it carries, including those three fragrance families. That’s what I look for when a company calls its fragrance clean. Can it point me to a standard I can read for myself? 

How you burn it matters too

Once you get the candle home, you have a say in how well it burns. Trim the wick to about ¼ inch before each use and clear the loose trimmings out of the wax. Burn it in a well-ventilated room, but keep the candle itself out of the breeze from a window, fan, or vent. If it keeps smoking, put it out and let it cool before trimming it again. With a well-made candle, a trimmed wick and a little fresh air go a long way. 

Santal Scented Candle Refillable · 40–50 hour burn · $60
Shop now
×